Central Banks Actions Indicate They Are Terrified…But Of What?

Graham Summers

A quick question for the “recovery” enthusiasts…

If the recovery is real and as strong as the “data” suggests…why are Central Banks engaged in the most aggressive stimulus in history?

Consider Europe.

According to the official data, the EU’s Services and Manufacturing PMI’s were 53.1 and 51.8 in August. Both were significantly above 50 (which represents contraction)…

Moreover, the EU’s inflation rate has risen over 0.4% in four months, rising from -0.2% in April to 0.2% today.

And yet, despite this data, the ECB continues to hold interest rates at -0.4% while also spending€80 billion per month in QE (the equivalent of $90 billion). At this pace, the ECB will spend nearly €1 TRILLION IN QE PER YEAR.

Put another way, the ECB is engaged in the most aggressive monetary policy in its history (even more aggressive than at the heart of the 2012 EU banking crisis) at a time when the EU economy, according to official data, is well above contraction.

Then there’s Japan.

According to the official data, the Japanese economy has “bounced back” and avoided recession, posting a growth rate of 0.5% in 1Q16.

Granted, this is not great, but it’s much better than the -0.4% growth rate for 4Q15.

On top of this, while Japan’s August Manufacturing PMI was 49.3 (just below contraction levels) it has been rising for the last three months from the low of sub-48 back in May. That same month Services PMI broke above contraction levels to 50.4.

Despite this, the Bank of Japan maintains interest rates at -0.1% and is currently spending nearly $800 billion per year buying assets. Astoundingly, the BoJ is actually buying all of Japan’s new Government debt issuance per year.

It is also is a top 5 shareholder for 81 of the 225 companies trading on the Nikkei 225. And it owns 60% of the Japan’s ETFs.

Put another way, like the ECB in Europe, the BoJ is engaged in the single most aggressive monetary policy in its history…at a time when, according to the data, Japan is NOT even in a recession.

Looking at this, it is obvious that something is very wrong. Either the data is inaccurate, or Central Banks know something we don’t. After all, they’re behaving as if they’re absolutely terrified at a time when the data is claiming their economies aren’t even in contraction!!!

Just what are they scared of?

We firmly believe the markets are preparing to enter another Crisis. With over 30% of global bonds posting negative yields, the financial system is a powder keg ready to blow.

The Bond Bubble is THE bubble. And with over $555 trillion in derivatives trading based on bond yields, this bubble is over 10 times the size of the one that nearly took down the system in 2008.

Graham Summers

Chief Market Strategist

Phoenix Capital Research

Click above logo for original story.

Be the first to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.